For equivalent expressions with negative and fractional powers, an allowed input can eliminate choices quickly. Evaluate the original and the choices in Desmos at a positive value; avoid if it could make two different forms equal. Then use exponent rules to prove the remaining form works for every allowed input. One mismatch disproves equivalence; one match doesn't prove it.
Hints
- Hint 1
Because , you can use to test the expressions in Desmos. If a choice gives a different value from the original, it cannot be equivalent, even if it matches at some other value.
- Hint 2
A negative exponent means a reciprocal: . In the first fraction, multiply the top and bottom by to remove the half powers. What does each term in the top become?
- Hint 3
Reversing a subtraction changes its sign: . If you reverse both numerator factors, their two negative signs cancel. Reversing only one changes the value of the product.
Step-by-step
Test a value, then prove the match
Step 1Evaluate the original at an allowed value
Since , choose rather than , where a subtraction could become zero and hide a sign error. Type , then type the original expression with in place of . Desmos prints .
- Step 2
Rule out values that do not match
Type the first two choices below the original, still using . Desmos prints and , respectively. Both differ from , so neither expression is equivalent to the original. Algebra can settle the other forms without relying on one test.
- Step 3
Clear the half powers in the first fraction
Because , is nonzero. Multiply the top and bottom of the first fraction by it:
Add exponents when multiplying powers of :
Divide top and bottom by :
- Step 4
Clear the negative exponent in the second fraction
The negative exponent means . Multiply the top and bottom of the second fraction by to clear it:
Add exponents on matching powers of :
Use , since :
- Step 5
Multiply the rewritten fractions
Multiply the numerators together and the denominators together. Powers of the same base add when multiplied, so :
- Step 6
Account for both reversed subtractions
Reversing a subtraction changes its sign. Reverse both numerator factors, not only one:
The two negative signs multiply to a positive:
So this expression is equivalent to the original for every . Choice D.