Matching stacks in two dot plots can show that one data set is a shifted copy of the other. Check that every stack keeps the same number of dots while its value moves by the same amount. The mean moves with the data, but standard deviation measures spread around each set’s own mean, not how large the values are.
Hints
- Hint 1
In a dot plot, each dot represents one student. Compare the stacks from left to right: does each stack in one club have the same number of dots as its partner in the other club?
- Hint 2
The mean is the total divided by the number of students. If every student’s page count rises by the same amount, the mean rises too. Does that rise change anyone’s distance from their club’s mean?
Step-by-step
Spot the shifted copy
Step 1Match the stacks
No Desmos needed. A matching shift in the dot plots answers both comparisons directly. In each dot plot, a stack’s height counts students. A’s stacks at have heights . B has those same heights at . So every B page count is its A counterpart plus .
- Step 2
Move the mean
The mean is the page total divided by the number of students. Since every count increases by and the number of students stays the same, B’s mean is A’s mean plus . You don’t need to calculate either mean separately.
- Step 3
Compare distances from each mean
Standard deviation measures spread around a club’s own mean. Let be any count in A and be A’s mean. The matching count in B is , and B’s mean is . Subtract each mean from its count:
So every count stays the same distance from its own mean. Adding the same amount to every value moves the mean but leaves standard deviation unchanged. B’s mean is pages greater than A’s, and their standard deviations are equal. Choice A.
Lessons that teach this
- SAT Data AnalysisIntermediateCoreReason with range and standard deviation
- SAT Data AnalysisIntermediateRead distributions and data displays
- SAT Data AnalysisBeginnerFind and interpret center
- DesmosIntermediateCoreSpread, standard deviation, and box plots in Desmos
- DesmosIntermediateMean, median, and frequency tables in Desmos