Question 174·Hard·Nonlinear Equations in One Variable; Systems in Two Variables
The equation
relates the positive real numbers , , and , with . Which equation correctly expresses in terms of and ?
For equations where a rational expression is squared and you must solve for a variable in the fraction, first take the square root of both sides and introduce a simple symbol like for the square root to clean up the algebra. Always remember that taking a square root produces both a positive and negative option; then use any given conditions (such as making a ratio positive) to discard the invalid sign. From there, treat the problem as a linear equation in : cross-multiply, collect like terms, factor out the variable, and carefully manage signs when simplifying the final fraction to match one of the answer choices.
Hints
Undo the square
The equation has . What operation will remove the square and make the equation simpler?
Introduce a simpler symbol
Let to avoid carrying the square root around. Rewrite the equation in terms of and and then solve for .
Use the condition on k
When you take a square root, you get both a positive and a negative possibility. How does the condition help you decide whether equals or ?
Isolate k carefully
After you set , cross-multiply and collect all the terms on one side. Factor out and solve, watching for sign changes when you move terms across the equals sign.
Desmos Guide
Choose simple test values for a and b
Because the relationship must hold for all positive and , you can pick convenient values that make simple. For example, set and , so that .
Solve the original equation numerically for k
In Desmos, enter the equation
as ((k+3)/(k-3))^2 = 4. Use the graph (or the solver in the table) to find the value of that satisfies this equation and is greater than 3. Note that there may be another solution that is not allowed by ; focus on the one that is larger than 3.
Evaluate each answer choice with the same a and b
Now, still using and , type in four separate expressions in Desmos corresponding to the answer choices, replacing with :
- A:
3*(1+sqrt(4))/(sqrt(4)-1) - B:
3*(1-sqrt(4))/(sqrt(4)+1) - C:
3*(sqrt(4)-1)/(sqrt(4)+1) - D:
3*(1-sqrt(4))/(1+sqrt(4))
Compare the numerical value of each expression with the valid value you found from the original equation. The choice whose value matches that is the correct formula.
Step-by-step Explanation
Undo the square with a square root
The equation is
Because and are positive, , so we can take the square root of both sides:
To make the algebra cleaner, let
Then the two possible equations become or . We will decide which one is valid using the condition on .
Use the condition to choose the correct sign
Since , both and are positive, so their ratio is also positive.
But is positive, and is negative. Therefore, the only equation that can be true is
We can now ignore the negative-root case, because it would give a value of that does not satisfy .
Solve the linear fractional equation for k
Starting from
cross-multiply:
Distribute on the right:
Move all terms to one side and constants to the other:
Factor on the left and on the right:
Now solve for by dividing both sides by :
Simplify the expression and substitute back for r
The expression
can be simplified by multiplying the numerator and denominator by (which does not change the value):
Now substitute back :
This matches choice A, so the correct equation is