Question 102·Hard·Nonlinear Equations in One Variable; Systems in Two Variables
Consider the system of equations
where is an integer constant.
If the system has no real solution, what is the least positive integer value of ?
(Express the answer as an integer)
For systems involving a circle and a line, a fast SAT approach is to substitute the line equation into the circle equation to get a quadratic in one variable, then use the discriminant to control the number of intersection points: set it equal to zero for tangency (one solution), greater than zero for two solutions, or less than zero for no real solutions. After simplifying the discriminant inequality in terms of the parameter (here, ), solve it carefully, then apply any extra conditions in the question such as "least positive integer" to pick the correct value efficiently.
Hints
Think about what the graphs represent
One equation is a circle and the other is a line . What does it mean about their intersection points if the system has no real solution?
Reduce the system to one equation
Try substituting the expression for from the line, , into the circle equation to get a single equation in . What type of equation will that be?
Connect the quadratic to number of solutions
Once you have a quadratic in , recall how the discriminant tells you whether there are 0, 1, or 2 real solutions. Which inequality should you use for "no real solution"?
Translate the discriminant condition to k and use integers
After you write and simplify the discriminant inequality in terms of , solve it and then think about which integer values satisfy it. Remember the question asks for the least positive integer.
Desmos Guide
Set up the circle and line with a slider for k
In Desmos, type (x-k)^2 + y^2 = 4 and y = 2x + 1. When you type k, Desmos will prompt you to create a slider for k; accept this so you can vary k continuously.
Observe intersections as k changes
Move the k slider and watch how the circle (whose center moves along the x-axis) intersects the fixed line. Notice for which values of k there are two intersection points, one point (tangent), or no intersection points.
Find the least positive integer k with no intersection
Gradually increase the slider and test positive integer values of k (for example, k = 1, 2, 3, ...). Look for the smallest positive integer at which the circle and the line do not intersect at all; that integer is the solution.
Step-by-step Explanation
Substitute the line into the circle
The system is
Substitute into the circle equation:
Now expand both squares:
Add them and move 4 to the left side:
Combine like terms:
So we have a quadratic in :
Relate "no real solution" to the discriminant
For a quadratic :
- Two real solutions if .
- One real solution (tangent) if .
- No real solutions if .
Here,
- ,
- ,
- .
We want no real solutions, so we need:
Simplify the discriminant inequality
First expand and :
- ,
- .
Substitute into the inequality:
Distribute the minus sign and combine like terms:
Multiply by (and flip the inequality sign):
Divide everything by 4 to simplify:
So must satisfy the inequality
Solve the inequality in k and find the least positive integer
First find where using the quadratic formula:
Compute the discriminant:
So
Approximate these:
- , so .
- ,
- .
Since the coefficient of in is positive, the inequality holds for
That is, for all less than about or greater than about . Among integers, this means
The question asks for the least positive integer that makes the system have no real solution, so the required value is .