Question 99·Hard·Equivalent Expressions
The quadratic expression , where is a constant, can be rewritten as , where , , and are integer constants. Which of the following values must be an integer?
For questions about rewriting quadratics and identifying expressions that must be integers, first expand the generic factored form and match coefficients to get equations relating the parameters. Use these to pin down specific integers (like the leading coefficient) and relationships (like a product equaling the constant term). Then rewrite each answer choice in terms of the integer parameters and analyze whether it is guaranteed to be an integer, often by recognizing divisor relationships or by finding a single concrete counterexample to show that an expression is not always integral. This coefficient-comparison approach is much faster and more reliable than trying to fully factor every possible case.
Hints
Connect the factored and expanded forms
Write out the product and expand it. Then match its coefficients with those of . What equations do you get for , , , and ?
Use the leading and constant terms
From matching coefficients, what must equal? What equation do you get from the constant term in terms of and ? Remember , , and are all integers.
Relate the answer choices to p, q, and r
Use your equations (especially , , and ) to rewrite each answer choice in terms of , , and . For A, B, and C, can you find specific integer values of and (with ) that make those expressions not integers?
Think about divisors of -28
Because and are integers with product , each is a divisor of . Use that idea to see which fraction in the choices is always equal to an integer like , , or (possibly up to a sign).
Desmos Guide
Set up the integer relationships
In Desmos, add definitions that mirror the algebra: type p = 9. Then choose an integer value for q that is a divisor of 28 (for example, use a slider q from -28 to 28 with step 1, but only stop on values that divide 28 evenly). Define r = -28/q. Finally define m = 9*r + q.
Enter the four answer expressions
On new lines, enter the four expressions from the choices: m/p, m/q, 28/p, and 28/q. Desmos will display numeric values for each expression based on your current q (and resulting r and m).
Test multiple integer factorizations
Move the q slider through different integer divisors of 28 (such as ±1, ±2, ±4, ±7, ±14, ±28). Each time, check which of the four expressions is always an integer while the others sometimes become non-integers. The expression that consistently remains an integer for all valid q values corresponds to the correct choice.
Step-by-step Explanation
Expand the factored form and match coefficients
Rewrite the given equality in expanded form.
Expand :
This must equal the original quadratic:
So the coefficients of like powers of must match:
- Coefficient of : .
- Coefficient of : .
- Constant term: .
Use the integer relationships among p, q, r, and m
From Step 1, we have three key equations, with all integers:
- (so is fixed).
- .
- .
Because and are integers and , and are integer factors of . That means there are many possible integer pairs satisfying , and for each such pair we get a (possibly different) .
Check expressions that are not guaranteed to be integers (A and B)
Now analyze some answer choices using and .
Choice A:
Using and :
This is an integer only when is a multiple of 9, which is not always true for factors of .
Example: Take , (since ). Then , so
which is not an integer. So does not have to be an integer.
Choice B:
Again use :
For this to always be an integer, would need to always be an integer, but that is not guaranteed.
Using the same example , gives and
which is not an integer. So does not have to be an integer.
Eliminate C and show which expression is always an integer
Now consider the remaining choices using the relationships above.
Choice C:
Since ,
which is not an integer. So is not guaranteed to be an integer.
For the last expression, use the constant-term equation .
From and , divide both sides by :
Since is an integer, must be an integer. That means
is also always an integer.
Therefore, the expression that must be an integer is
which corresponds to choice D.