Question 75·Hard·Equivalent Expressions
If , which of the following is equivalent to
For expression-equivalence questions with exponents, first simplify the given expression yourself: factor out common terms, use exponent rules ( and ), and cancel where possible before looking at the choices. Once you have a clean form—often a single fraction—compare its structure (especially signs in factors like vs. ) to the answer choices instead of trying to expand everything. If you’re unsure, you can also plug in a simple allowed value (like or , avoiding values that make denominators zero) into the original expression and each choice to quickly rule out incorrect options.
Hints
Separate the two fractions
Before multiplying, try simplifying each fraction on its own. Focus first on , then on .
Use exponent rules in the first fraction
In the first fraction, factor out the greatest common factor from the numerator. What common numerical and -power factor do and share, and how does dividing powers of work ()?
Simplify the second fraction term by term
For , divide each term in the numerator by . Use the exponent rule and then rewrite any negative exponents as fractions.
After multiplying, look at factor signs
Once you multiply the simplified fractions, you should get something like over a power of . How can you factor out from each of these to rewrite them in the more standard and forms?
Desmos Guide
Enter the original expression as a function
In Desmos, type something like
so you can evaluate or graph the original expression for positive (remember the problem states , so only look at ).
Enter each answer choice as separate functions
Define functions for each option, for example:
- These represent the four answer choices in terms of .
Compare values or graphs for positive inputs
Use Desmos’s table feature (click the gear icon next to each function and add a table) or visually inspect the graphs for . Pick a few positive -values (like ) and compare to each option’s value. The option whose function always matches for these positive values is the equivalent expression.
Step-by-step Explanation
Simplify the first fraction
Work with
Factor from the numerator:
Next factor out from the parentheses. Since :
So the numerator is , and the whole fraction becomes
Simplify the second fraction
Now simplify
Divide each term in the numerator by :
Rewrite with positive exponents and a single denominator:
Multiply the two simplified fractions
Now multiply the results from Steps 1 and 2:
Multiply the numerators and denominators:
This is a simplified, factored form of the original expression, but we can rewrite the factors in a more standard order.
Rewrite factors to match an answer choice
Rewrite each factor so that the variable term comes first.
Note that
So the numerator becomes
(because the product of two negatives is positive).
Therefore, the original expression is equivalent to
which corresponds to choice A.