Question 72·Hard·Equivalent Expressions
Which of the following is equivalent to
for all such that the expression is defined?
For this type of SAT question, immediately look for factoring patterns—especially difference of squares/cubes and perfect square trinomials—so you can rewrite the expression in fully factored form. Then systematically cancel identical factors in the numerator and denominator, being careful to cancel only whole factors (not parts of sums) and to note any domain restrictions from the original denominators. Once everything that can cancel is gone, read off the remaining simplified expression and match it to the answer choice.
Hints
Look for special factoring patterns
Notice that and are both standard patterns: one is a difference of cubes and the other is a perfect square trinomial. Factor them first.
Factor the numerator and first denominator
Use to factor , and recognize as .
Rewrite and cancel common factors
After you rewrite the whole expression with factors, look for the same factors in any numerator and denominator and cancel them. Then see what is left.
Desmos Guide
Graph the original expression
In Desmos, enter the function
y1 = (x^3 - 8)/(x^2 - 4x + 4) * (x - 2)/(x^2 + 2x + 4)
You should see a horizontal line (with possibly a missing point at where the original expression is undefined). Note the constant -value of this line.
Compare with each answer choice
Now enter each option as its own function: y2 = x - 2, y3 = x + 2, and y4 = x^2 - 2x + 4. Visually compare their graphs with y1. The correct choice is the one whose graph matches the horizontal line of y1 for all in the domain of the original expression (except the hole at ).
Step-by-step Explanation
Factor each polynomial
First, factor the pieces of the expression:
- is a difference of cubes. Using with and :
- is a perfect square trinomial:
- The quadratic does not factor nicely over the reals, so leave it as is.
Now rewrite the original expression with these factorizations:
Cancel common factors and simplify
Now look for factors that appear in both a numerator and a denominator:
- There is a factor of in the first numerator and in the first denominator. One cancels, leaving a single in the denominator.
- There is a factor of in the first numerator and in the second denominator; these cancel completely.
- The remaining in the denominator cancels with the in the second numerator.
Writing this out:
for all where the original expression is defined (note because of the original denominators). So the entire expression is equivalent to .