Question 39·Hard·Equivalent Expressions
The cubic polynomial , where and are constants, can be rewritten in the form , where , , , and are integers.
Which of the following expressions must be an integer?
For factorization-structure questions, quickly expand the given factored form symbolically, then match coefficients of each power of with the original polynomial to get simple equations relating the constants. Start with the leading term to fix the main coefficient, then use the constant term—especially when it involves a prime—to restrict possible integer values. Finally, plug these constraints into each answer choice to see which expression must always be an integer (or have whatever property the question asks), using a single clear counterexample to eliminate any choice that is not guaranteed.
Hints
Use the structure of the factoring
First, expand and group like terms so you can compare it directly to .
Match coefficients of corresponding powers of x
Compare the coefficients of , , , and the constant term from both expressions. What equations do you get for , , and ?
Focus on the constant term and the prime number 17
From the constant terms you get . Since 17 is prime and and are integers, what are the only possible integer values of ?
Check each option using what you know about m and n
Use and the fact that must be a divisor of 17. For each choice, ask: does this expression have to be an integer for all allowed values of (and all integer )?
Desmos Guide
Use specific integer values consistent with the conditions
In Desmos, define m = 2. Then try one allowed value for n, such as n = 1, and choose simple integers like p = 0, q = 17 so that n*q = 17 is satisfied. Now define a = 2*p + n and create the four expressions a/m, a/n, 17/m, and 17/n. Observe which of these is a whole number. Then repeat with other possible values of n (17, -1, -17) that keep n*q = 17 true, and see which expression stays a whole number for every allowed choice of n. The one that is always a whole number is the correct choice.
Step-by-step Explanation
Expand the factored form
Write out the product of and :
Now collect like terms:
This must equal for all .
Match the leading coefficient to find m
Compare the coefficients of :
- From , the coefficient is .
- From , the coefficient is .
So .
This already lets you say something about expressions that involve .
Use the constant term to relate n and q
Now compare the constant terms (the terms without ):
- From the expanded form, the constant term is .
- From the original polynomial, the constant term is .
So
Since and are integers and 17 is a prime number, the only possible integer factor pairs are:
- .
Express a and connect it to m and n
Match the coefficient of to understand how depends on , , and :
- From the expanded form, the coefficient is .
- From the original polynomial, the coefficient is .
So
Using , this becomes
This shows that depends on both and and is not fixed by alone.
Test which expression must always be an integer
We now know:
- , so any expression with is determined.
- must be one of .
- , where is any integer.
Consider each option:
- , which is not an integer.
- , which is not always an integer because can be odd.
- , which is not guaranteed to be an integer since and are independent integers.
- For : since must be a divisor of (one of ), is always an integer.
Therefore, the expression that must be an integer is .