Question 183·Hard·Equivalent Expressions
Which expression is equivalent to
For rational-expression equivalence questions, first factor any quadratic denominators to reveal common factors, then rewrite each fraction with a common denominator and combine the numerators in one clear step. Be especially careful with subtraction: write the combined numerator with parentheses (like ) and explicitly distribute the minus sign before simplifying. Finally, compare your simplified numerator to the choices, watching for sign reversals and small constant errors that distinguish very similar-looking options.
Hints
Look at the denominators
Can you factor ? Think about the pattern .
Create a common denominator
Once is factored, what common denominator can you use for both fractions, and what do you need to multiply the first fraction by to get it?
Be careful with subtraction
When you combine the fractions, the expression becomes one big numerator over a common denominator. Make sure you subtract the entire second numerator, not just part of it—distribute the minus sign.
Simplify the numerator
After expanding and distributing, group like terms in the numerator (the terms and the constant terms). Then compare that simplified numerator to the numerators in the choices.
Desmos Guide
Enter the original expression
In Desmos, type the original expression as y = 2/(x-4) - (3x+1)/(x^2-16) so you can see its graph.
Enter each answer choice to compare
On separate lines, enter each choice, for example y = (7-x)/((x-4)(x+4)), y = (x-7)/((x-4)(x+4)), etc. Make sure parentheses match the given denominators exactly.
Check which graph matches the original
Look at the graphs: the correct choice will produce a graph that lies exactly on top of the graph of the original expression for all where the expression is defined. The others will differ in slope or position, especially for positive and negative values.
Confirm numerically if needed
You can also pick a few -values (avoiding where the expression is undefined), use the Desmos table for each function, and see which choice always gives the same -values as the original expression.
Step-by-step Explanation
Factor the quadratic denominator
Notice that is a difference of squares:
So the original expression becomes
Rewrite with a common denominator
To combine the fractions, they need the same denominator. The second fraction already has denominator .
For the first fraction , multiply top and bottom by :
Now the expression is
Combine the numerators and distribute the minus sign
Now that the denominators match, subtract the numerators over the common denominator:
First expand :
So the numerator becomes
Distribute the minus sign across :
Simplify the numerator and match the answer choice
Combine like terms in the numerator:
- For the terms: .
- For the constants: .
So the numerator simplifies to , which is the same as .
Therefore the whole expression becomes
which matches answer choice A.