Question 180·Hard·Equivalent Expressions
For all real numbers for which it is defined, which of the following expressions is equivalent to
For rational-expression equivalence questions, first factor the numerator and denominator completely using common patterns (GCF, difference of squares, perfect square trinomials). Then cancel only common factors (never terms in a sum or difference) while keeping track of values that make the denominator zero. As a quick check, you can plug in a simple value of that does not make any denominator zero into both the original and each answer choice to see which expression always matches.
Hints
Start by factoring the numerator
Look at . Can you factor out a greatest common factor first, then factor the remaining quadratic?
Recognize special factoring patterns
After factoring out from the numerator, check whether the quadratic is a perfect square trinomial. Also, notice that the denominator has the form .
Use cancellation carefully
Once both numerator and denominator are fully factored, identify any common factors you can cancel. Remember you can only cancel factors (multipliers), not terms in a sum or difference, and you must avoid values of that make the denominator zero.
Desmos Guide
Enter the original expression
In Desmos, type the original function as
f(x) = (x^3 - 6x^2 + 9x)/(x^2 - 9)
and note that it will be undefined at and (there will be holes or breaks there).
Enter each answer choice as a separate function
Type each choice as its own function, for example:
g(x) = x(x-3)/(x+3)h(x) = x(x+3)/(x-3)p(x) = (x-3)/(x+3)q(x) = x/(x+3)
Make sure you use parentheses exactly as written.
Compare graphs or tables
Either:
- Turn on the graphs and see which choice has the same graph as everywhere that is defined (ignoring the points where is undefined), or
- Use a table (click the gear next to each function, then "Table") and compare values of with each choice at several values like . The correct choice will always match at these values, while the others will not.
Step-by-step Explanation
Factor the numerator
Start with the numerator:
First, factor out the greatest common factor :
Now factor the quadratic . Notice it is a perfect square trinomial:
- is
- is
- The middle term is
So:
Thus the numerator becomes:
Factor the denominator
Now factor the denominator:
This is a difference of squares:
So:
Write the rational expression in completely factored form
Substitute the factored forms of the numerator and denominator into the original fraction:
Now the expression is fully factored, so we can see common factors in the numerator and denominator.
Cancel common factors and identify the equivalent expression
The numerator and denominator both contain a factor of .
For and (the values that make the denominator zero), we can cancel one factor of :
So, for all real numbers where the original expression is defined (that is, and ), the expression is equivalent to
This matches choice A.