Question 123·Hard·Equivalent Expressions
Which expression is equivalent to
For rational expression equivalence questions, first factor any quadratic denominators, then choose the least common denominator that includes all factors. Rewrite each fraction with this common denominator, combine the numerators carefully (paying close attention to minus signs), simplify the resulting numerator, and then match the simplified single fraction to the answer choices. If time allows, quickly plug in a simple value of the variable (avoiding values that make denominators zero) to check which option gives the same result as the original expression.
Hints
Look at the denominators
How can you rewrite so that it relates to and ? Think about the difference of squares pattern .
Find a common denominator
Once you factor , what denominator could all three fractions share? How can you adjust the second and third fractions so they have this same denominator?
Combine and simplify the numerators
After rewriting all fractions with the same denominator, put them over a single denominator and carefully expand and combine like terms in the numerator. Watch the minus sign in front of .
Desmos Guide
Enter the original expression
In Desmos, type the original expression as a function, for example: f(k) = 2k/(k^2 - 9) - 3/(k - 3) + (k + 5)/(k + 3).
Enter each answer choice as separate functions
Define each option as a new function, such as A(k) = (k^2 - k - 24)/(k^2 - 9), B(k) = (k^2 + k - 24)/(k^2 + 9), C(k) = (k^2 + k - 24)/(k^2 - 6k + 9), and D(k) = (k^2 + k - 24)/(k^2 - 9).
Compare values for several k-values
Use a table (click the gear icon next to one function and add a table) to evaluate f(k) and each of A(k), B(k), C(k), and D(k) at several values like (avoid , where denominators are zero). Look for which option’s values always match .
Confirm visually with graphs (optional)
On the graph, look for the option whose graph lies exactly on top of the graph of f(k) (except at excluded points where there are holes or vertical asymptotes). That function represents the equivalent expression.
Step-by-step Explanation
Factor the denominators and find a common denominator
Notice that the first denominator is , which is a difference of squares:
So the common denominator for all three fractions can be (which is the same as ).
Rewrite each fraction with the common denominator
Rewrite each term so it has denominator :
- First term: already has denominator .
- Second term:
- Multiply top and bottom by to get
- .
- Third term:
- Multiply top and bottom by to get
- .
Now the expression is
Combine the numerators into a single fraction
Since all three fractions have the same denominator, combine them into one fraction by adding/subtracting the numerators:
Now expand and simplify the numerator:
- Expand .
- Expand .
So the numerator becomes
Combine like terms:
- .
- .
So the numerator simplifies to . The denominator is still .
Write the final simplified expression and match the choice
The whole expression simplifies to
This matches answer choice D, so is the equivalent expression.