Question 84·200 Super-Hard SAT Math Questions·Advanced Math
In the given equation, is a constant. The equation has exactly one real solution. Which choice is the minimum possible value of ?
When a parameter equation involves a square root equaling a linear expression, first enforce the nonnegativity condition on the linear side. Then use a substitution that makes the linear expression a single variable (like ), square to get a quadratic, and use discriminant/sign reasoning to control the number of valid solutions (especially paying attention to restrictions like ). Finally, compare the parameter values from the different “exactly one solution” cases to find the minimum requested expression.
Hints
Use the fact that a square root is nonnegative
Since , the expression must also be . Consider substituting a new variable for .
Turn it into a quadratic
After substituting , isolate the square root and square both sides to get a quadratic equation in .
Count solutions using discriminant and signs
To have exactly one real solution in , you need exactly one solution with . Think about when a quadratic has (1) a double root or (2) one positive and one negative root.
Desmos Guide
Graph both sides with a slider
Enter and . Create a slider for .
Find when there is exactly one intersection
Move the slider downward from a large value. Watch the graphs: for some values there will be one intersection, then at a certain point it will switch to two intersections, and below that there will be none.
Identify the boundary case
Adjust to the boundary where the two-intersection case just turns into one intersection (the line and curve just touch). Click the intersection point to confirm there is only one.
Compute from the slider value
Read the slider value of at that boundary and multiply by 16. Match that result to the answer choice.
Step-by-step Explanation
Substitute to control the square root condition
Because , the right side must satisfy .
Let (so and ). Then the equation becomes
Square and write a quadratic in
Inside the square root,
So
Squaring both sides (valid because both sides are nonnegative) gives
Multiply by 2:
Determine when there is exactly one valid (nonnegative) root
The discriminant is
For at least one real solution, , so .
Now consider the constant term of the quadratic in , which is :
-
If , then , so . The product of the roots is negative, so one root is positive and the other is negative. Since we also require , this produces exactly one valid .
-
If , then , so . The product of the roots is positive and the sum of the roots is , so (when real) both roots are positive, giving two solutions. The only way to get exactly one solution in this case is if the roots merge into a double root, meaning .
-
If , then gives and , which are two solutions, so this case is not allowed.
Find the minimum possible value of
From the analysis, the equation has exactly one real solution when either:
- (which would make ), or
- , which gives
Since , the minimum possible value of is 239.