Question 191·200 Super-Hard SAT Math Questions·Problem Solving and Data Analysis
Data set consists of 5 numbers. The mean of data set is 10, and the range of data set is 12.
Data set is created by adding 4 to each number in data set . Data set is then created by adding one more number to data set ; the added number is equal to the mean of data set .
Which choice best describes which of the following statements must be true?
I. The mean of data set is 14.
II. The median of data set is 14.
III. The standard deviation of data set is less than the standard deviation of data set .
Keep the construction separate: first analyze what adding 4 does to center/spread (mean shifts, standard deviation stays the same), then analyze what happens when you add one extra value equal to the current mean (mean stays the same, and spread decreases because you add a zero-deviation point). For any statement about a statistic like the median that depends on ordering, a single counterexample is enough to show it is not a “must be true” statement.
Hints
Track how the mean changes when all values shift
When you add the same constant to every value in a data set, the mean changes by that constant.
Use the definition of mean as “sum divided by count”
After you know the mean of , you can find the sum of the 5 numbers in , then update the sum and count after adding the extra number.
For “must be true” statements, look for counterexamples
To test the median claim, try building one specific 5-number data set with mean 10 and range 12, then follow the two-step construction to see what the median becomes.
Think about deviations from the mean
For standard deviation, focus on what happens to the deviations from the mean when you add a new value that is exactly equal to the mean.
Desmos Guide
Create an example data set that satisfies the conditions
Enter a list such as A=[5,8,9,11,17]. Verify it has mean 10 by typing mean(A) and compute its range by typing max(A)-min(A).
Build by adding 4 to each value, then confirm its mean
Type C=A+4 and then mean(C) to confirm the mean of .
Build by adding one more value equal to the mean of
Type B=join(C,[mean(C)]). Then compute mean(B) and median(B) to see whether the median claim holds for this valid example.
Compare standard deviations numerically across examples
Type stdev(A) and stdev(B). Then try a different valid list (keep mean 10 and range 12) and recompute to see which statements keep working across all examples you test.
Step-by-step Explanation
Find the mean of the shifted data set
Adding 4 to every value increases the mean by 4.
So, since the mean of is 10, the mean of is .
Use the fact that adding the mean does not change the mean
Data set is formed by taking the 5 values of and adding one more value equal to the mean of , which is 14.
If a data set has mean 14, then the sum of its 5 values is .
After adding one more value of 14, the new sum is , and there are 6 values, so the mean of is .
Thus statement I must be true.
Check whether the median must be 14 (it does not)
The median of a 6-number data set is the average of the 3rd and 4th values when ordered.
Statement II is not guaranteed. For example, let
This has mean and range , so it is allowed.
Then
and is plus an extra 14:
The 3rd and 4th values are 13 and 14, so the median is , not 14. Therefore, statement II does not have to be true.
Compare standard deviations
Adding 4 to every value does not change standard deviation, so data sets and have the same standard deviation.
Now compare (5 values) to (the same 5 values plus one extra value equal to the mean 14). Let the mean of both and be .
For , let
Then the variance of is .
When forming , we add one more value equal to , so its squared deviation is . The sum of squared deviations stays , but it is now averaged over 6 values, so the variance of is .
Since the range of is 12, the values are not all equal, so . Therefore,
So , and statement III must be true.
Therefore, the correct choice is I and III only.