Question 15·Hard·Words in Context
Yet unlike her contemporaries, who often veered between deference and outright flattery, Wright delivered criticism so ______ that even her harshest reviews were avidly read as models of lucidity.
Which choice completes the text with the most logical and precise word or phrase?
For SAT Words-in-Context questions, first read the entire sentence and identify key clues: contrast words (like “yet” or “however”) and result clauses (like “so ___ that…”). Paraphrase the sentence in your own words to decide what kind of word (positive/negative, clear/unclear, strong/weak) must fill the blank. Then, quickly recall or infer the meanings of the answer choices and eliminate any that conflict with those clues. Finally, plug the remaining option(s) back into the sentence to confirm that the tone and meaning stay consistent.
Hints
Look for contrast words
Focus on the word “Yet” and the phrase “unlike her contemporaries.” How were her contemporaries described, and what kind of criticism would be the opposite of that?
Pay attention to the result of her criticism
Look closely at the phrase “so ______ that even her harshest reviews were avidly read as models of lucidity.” What quality of writing would make even harsh reviews widely read and admired for their clarity?
Match the word to the tone and meaning
Think about the overall tone: is Wright’s criticism being described as unclear, outdated, vague, or something else? Quickly recall or look up the basic meaning of each option and see which one fits best with “models of lucidity.”
Step-by-step Explanation
Understand the contrast in the sentence
The sentence starts with “Yet unlike her contemporaries”, which sets up a contrast between Wright and other critics.
- Her contemporaries “veered between deference and outright flattery,” meaning they were overly polite and flattering instead of being straightforwardly critical.
- Wright’s criticism is being contrasted with that: it was different in style and tone.
Use the result clause as the key clue
Look at the second half: “so ______ that even her harshest reviews were avidly read as models of lucidity.”
- “So ___ that” shows cause and effect.
- Because her criticism was so [blank], even her harshest reviews were avidly read and seen as models of lucidity.
- “Lucidity” means clarity. So the missing word must describe criticism that is very clear and effective, not vague, wordy, or confusing.
Test each choice against the meaning of the sentence
Now check each option against what we need (clear, effective, strong criticism that people admired for its clarity):
- diffuse: spread out, wordy, or poorly organized — the opposite of concise clarity.
- obsolescent: becoming outdated — doesn’t describe a style of criticism in a way that explains “models of lucidity.”
- equivocal: ambiguous or having more than one possible meaning — again, the opposite of lucid.
- trenchant: sharply effective, forceful, and clear in expression. Only “trenchant” fits criticism that is admired as a model of clarity, so D) trenchant is correct.