Question 41·Medium·Two-Variable Data: Models and Scatterplots
A biology student recorded the size of a bacterial colony at regular intervals.
| Time (hours) | Colony size (thousands of bacteria) |
|---|---|
| 0 | 2.0 |
| 1 | 3.1 |
| 2 | 4.8 |
| 3 | 7.3 |
| 4 | 11.1 |
Based on the data, which type of function would best model the relationship between time and colony size for the interval shown?
For questions asking which function type best models data, quickly check the pattern of change: compute a few differences between consecutive y-values to test for linear (constant difference), then a few second differences for quadratic (constant second difference). If neither is close, compute a couple of ratios (new y ÷ old y); if these are roughly constant, that indicates exponential behavior. Also consider the direction of change: inverse variation typically decreases as x increases and cannot include x = 0, which can help you quickly rule it out.
Hints
First compare consecutive values
Look at how much the colony size increases from one hour to the next. Do these increases look about the same, or are they getting larger?
Think about different growth patterns
One function type fits data where the y-value grows by the same amount each step, another where the second differences are about the same, and another where the y-value grows by about the same percentage or factor each step. Which pattern seems closest here?
Use ratios, not just differences
Try dividing each colony size by the previous one (for example, , then ). Are those ratios roughly the same number? That points you toward one particular type of model.
Desmos Guide
Enter the data as a table
Create a table in Desmos. In the first column (say ), enter the times: 0, 1, 2, 3, 4. In the second column (), enter the colony sizes: 2, 3.1, 4.8, 7.3, 11.1. This will display the scatterplot of the data.
Test a linear model with regression
In a new expression line, type y1 ~ m x1 + b. Desmos will find a best-fit line. Look at how closely this line matches the plotted points—especially at the higher times.
Test a quadratic model with regression
In another expression line, type y1 ~ a x1^2 + b x1 + c. Compare this curve to the scatterplot. See whether it goes through or near all the points or if it misses especially at the ends.
Test an exponential model with regression
In a new line, type y1 ~ a b^x1. Desmos will fit an exponential curve to the data. Compare this curve’s shape and closeness to the points with the linear and quadratic fits from the previous steps.
(Optional) Visualize an inverse variation
You can type an equation like y = k/x using a slider for to see the general shape of an inverse variation. Compare that shape to your scatterplot—pay attention to whether it increases or decreases as increases and whether it can even pass through a point with .
Step-by-step Explanation
Check for a linear pattern (constant increase)
For a linear model, the difference between consecutive y-values (colony sizes) should be roughly constant.
Compute the differences:
- From 0 to 1 hour:
- From 1 to 2 hours:
- From 2 to 3 hours:
- From 3 to 4 hours:
These increases are not close to constant; they are getting larger each time, so a linear function is not a good fit.
Check for a quadratic pattern (constant second differences)
For a quadratic model, the second differences (the differences of the differences) should be roughly constant.
We already have the first differences: , , , . Now find the second differences:
- Between and :
- Between and :
- Between and :
These second differences are not close to constant, so a quadratic function is unlikely to be the best model.
Check for an inverse variation pattern
For an inverse variation model, the product is roughly constant and usually decreases as increases.
Here, as time increases from 0 to 4 hours, the colony size increases instead of decreasing. That behavior does not match inverse variation, so we can rule out that option as well.
Look for a multiplicative (constant ratio) pattern
When data are best modeled by an exponential function, the y-values change by about the same factor (ratio) each step, not the same difference.
Compute the ratios of consecutive colony sizes:
- From 0 to 1 hour:
- From 1 to 2 hours:
- From 2 to 3 hours:
- From 3 to 4 hours:
These ratios are all around , meaning the colony is growing by roughly the same factor each hour. That pattern is best modeled by an exponential function.