Question 48·Hard·Probability and Conditional Probability
A factory operates three machines to produce identical steel bolts in a single workday.
| Machine | Number of bolts produced | Percentage that are defective |
|---|---|---|
| X | 3,000 | 1.2% |
| Y | 5,000 | 1.8% |
| Z | 2,000 | 2.5% |
At the end of the day, one bolt is selected at random from the entire day's production and found to be defective. What is the probability that the defective bolt was produced by Machine Z?
For SAT conditional probability questions involving groups with different percentages, convert everything to counts first. Multiply each group's size by its given percentage to find the number of items with the specified property (here, defective bolts). Then, because you are given that the chosen item has that property, restrict your attention to this subset: the conditional probability becomes (count from the group of interest) ÷ (total count with the property). Work with simple fractions and reduce carefully to avoid arithmetic mistakes.
Hints
Focus on the condition
You are told the bolt is defective. Among only the defective bolts, you want the probability that it was made by Machine Z. How can you count these defective bolts?
Turn percentages into counts
For each machine, multiply the number of bolts produced by the defect percentage (as a decimal) to find how many defective bolts that machine produces.
Build the conditional probability
Once you know how many defective bolts each machine made, think: what fraction of all defective bolts came from Machine Z?
Desmos Guide
Compute the number of defective bolts from each machine
In Desmos, type:
x = 3000*0.012y = 5000*0.018z = 2000*0.025
and note the values of x, y, and z (the defective counts for X, Y, and Z).
Find the total number of defective bolts
In Desmos, type total = x + y + z to get the total number of defective bolts from all machines.
Form the conditional probability and compare to choices
In Desmos, type p = z / total to get the probability that a randomly chosen defective bolt came from Machine Z. Then, in separate lines, type each answer choice as a fraction (for example, 25/88, 9/44, 5/22, 1/4) and compare their decimal values to p to see which one matches.
Step-by-step Explanation
Identify what probability is being asked
We are told the selected bolt is defective and asked for the probability that it came from Machine Z.
This is a conditional probability:
An easier way in this context is to work with counts: among all defective bolts, what fraction were produced by Machine Z?
Find the number of defective bolts from each machine
Use "number produced × percent defective" for each machine.
- Machine X: defective bolts.
- Machine Y: defective bolts.
- Machine Z: defective bolts.
So the defective counts are 36 from X, 90 from Y, and 50 from Z.
Compute the total number of defective bolts and set up the fraction
Add the defective bolts from all three machines:
So there are 176 defective bolts in total. Among these, 50 are from Machine Z.
The conditional probability is therefore
Simplify the fraction and match to the answer choices
Now simplify .
Both 50 and 176 are divisible by 2:
and have no common factor other than 1, so is fully simplified. This matches choice B, so the correct answer is .