Question 27·Hard·Probability and Conditional Probability
A company uses two machines, Machine A and Machine B, to manufacture identical metal pins. Machine A produces 40% of the pins, and Machine B produces the rest. The defect rate for Machine B is 2 percentage points higher than the defect rate for Machine A. Overall, 4.2% of all pins produced in one day are defective.
The company improves only Machine A so that the overall defective rate becomes 3.6%, while Machine B’s defect rate stays the same.
By how many percentage points must Machine A’s defect rate decrease?
For machine-mixture defect problems, treat each defect rate as a conditional probability and use a weighted average: (share from A)(rate of A) + (share from B)(rate of B) = overall rate. If the situation changes, write a second weighted-average equation for the new overall rate, keeping any “unchanged” machine’s rate fixed, then subtract old and new rates in percentage points.
Hints
Solve for the original defect rates first
Let be Machine A’s defect rate (decimal) and use to find .
Machine B stays the same in the second situation
Once you know Machine B’s defect rate, treat it as a fixed number in the new weighted-average equation for the 3.6% overall defect rate.
Percentage points means subtract the percents
After you find Machine A’s new defect rate, subtract (old %) − (new %) to get the decrease in percentage points.
Desmos Guide
Find Machine A’s original defect rate
In Desmos, enter 0.40x + 0.60(x+0.02) - 0.042 and find the value of where the graph crosses (the -intercept). This gives Machine A’s original defect rate as a decimal.
Use the new overall defective rate to find
In Desmos, enter 0.40x + 0.60*0.05 - 0.036 and find the value of where the graph crosses (the -intercept). This value is , Machine A’s new defect rate as a decimal.
Convert to percentage points
Subtract the two decimal rates you found (original minus new), then multiply by to convert the result to percentage points and match it to the answer choices.
Step-by-step Explanation
Find the original defect rates
Let be Machine A’s defect rate (decimal). Then Machine B’s defect rate is .
Using the overall defective rate as a weighted average:
So
meaning Machine A is at and Machine B is at .
Set up the new overall defective rate after improving Machine A
Let be Machine A’s new defect rate (decimal). Machine B stays at .
The new overall defective rate is 3.6%, so
Solve for Machine A’s new defect rate
Compute , so
So Machine A’s new defect rate is .
Compute the decrease in percentage points
Machine A decreases from to , a decrease of (percentage points).
Therefore, the correct answer is (choice B).