Question 57·Hard·One-Variable Data Distributions; Measures of Center and Spread
Data set E consists of 11 distinct integers, each between 20 and 80, inclusive. Ten of the integers are listed below.
22, 24, 37, 43, 45, 49, 53, 54, 56, 58
If the median of data set E is 49 and the mean of data set E is an integer, what is the least possible value of the largest integer in data set E?
(Express the answer as an integer)
For data-set questions that mix median and mean, first use the median to pin down where the unknown value must fall in the ordered list (for example, greater than or less than a specific number so the median position stays fixed). Then compute the sum of the known values and write the mean of the full set in terms of the unknown; impose the condition that this mean is an integer by requiring the total sum to be a multiple of the number of data points. Finally, list all candidate values that satisfy the divisibility condition and the range, discard any that violate distinctness or the median requirement, and choose the one that fits the question’s request (smallest, largest, etc.) as quickly as possible.
Hints
Think about what the median tells you
With 11 numbers, the median is the 6th number when they are ordered from least to greatest. Look at the given list in order: where is 49 now, and what must be true about the new number so that 49 stays the 6th number?
Use the mean being an integer
Find the sum of the 10 given numbers. Then write an expression for the mean of all 11 numbers in terms of the unknown number. What condition must the numerator satisfy so that dividing by 11 gives an integer?
Narrow down possible values for the unknown number
Once you know what type of numbers the unknown must be (for example, based on a remainder when divided by 11), list all such numbers between 20 and 80. Then remove any that are already in the data set or that would change the median away from 49.
Desmos Guide
Compute the sum of the known numbers and express the mean
In Desmos, type 441 to confirm the sum of the 10 given numbers (or type 22+24+37+43+45+49+53+54+56+58 and see the result). Then type (441 + x)/11 so Desmos shows the mean as a function of the unknown number x.
Use a slider to find x values that give an integer mean
Click on x in (441 + x)/11 to create a slider. Edit the slider so that x goes from 20 to 80 and has step 1. Move the slider and watch the numerical value of (441 + x)/11; note the x values between 20 and 80 where the output is an integer.
Filter for valid and minimal largest values
From the x values that give an integer mean, ignore any that are already in the data set or are less than or equal to 49 (they would change the median). Among the remaining valid x values, the smallest one will be the least possible value of the largest integer in the data set; read that value of x from Desmos.
Step-by-step Explanation
Use the median to restrict where the unknown number can be
There are 11 integers in data set E. When the numbers are listed in increasing order, the median of 11 numbers is the 6th number.
We already have these 10 numbers, in order:
22, 24, 37, 43, 45, 49, 53, 54, 56, 58
Here, 49 is already the 6th number. For the median of the full 11-number data set to still be 49:
- The 6th number must remain 49.
- That means we must still have exactly 5 numbers less than 49.
If the new number were less than 49, then there would be 6 numbers less than 49, so the median would no longer be 49. Therefore, the unknown integer must be greater than 49.
Write an equation for the mean to be an integer
Let be the unknown integer. The sum of the 10 known integers is:
So the total sum of all 11 integers is .
The mean (average) is
We are told this mean is an integer, so must be a multiple of 11.
Since , we know is 1 more than a multiple of 11. To make a multiple of 11, must be 10 more than some multiple of 11 (so that is a multiple of 11). In other words, has remainder 10 when divided by 11.
List all possible values of x between 20 and 80
Numbers between 20 and 80 that leave a remainder of 10 when divided by 11 are:
- (since )
- (since )
- (since )
- (since )
- (since )
- (since )
So, based only on the mean being an integer and the range 20 to 80, could be , or .
Apply all conditions to find the least possible largest integer
Now use all the conditions:
-
Distinct integers: cannot equal any of the existing numbers.
- The existing numbers are 22, 24, 37, 43, 45, 49, 53, 54, 56, 58.
- So cannot be or from our candidate list.
-
Median is 49: From Step 1, must be greater than 49.
- That eliminates and .
After removing , and , the only remaining possibilities for are 65 and 76.
Since will be larger than 58, itself will be the largest integer in the data set. We are asked for the least possible value of the largest integer, so we choose the smaller of the two possibilities:
.