Question 54·Hard·One-Variable Data Distributions; Measures of Center and Spread
The frequency distribution below summarizes a data set containing values, where is a positive integer.
| Value | Frequency |
|---|---|
| 1 | |
| 2 | |
| 3 | |
| 4 | |
| 5 | |
| 10 |
How much greater is the mean of the data set than the median?
For frequency-table questions with a variable like , treat symbolically instead of trying to pick a specific number: write the total sum as the sum of (value × frequency), factor or simplify, and divide by the total frequency to get the mean—often the variable cancels. For the median, use cumulative frequencies to locate the exact positions of the middle data points (for even, the -th and -st values) and read off which value they correspond to. Finally, perform the required comparison (such as mean minus median) and match the result to the choices.
Hints
Express the mean using the frequency table
To find the mean, you need the total sum of all data values and the total number of values. How can you use "value × frequency" for each row to get the sum?
Notice how appears in every frequency
When you compute the mean, both the numerator (sum) and the denominator (number of values) will include . Think about what happens to when you simplify the fraction.
Think carefully about the median’s position
There are data points. For an even number of points, which two positions do you average to get the median? Use cumulative frequencies (adding up counts as you go down the table) to see which value those positions land on.
Final step: compare mean and median
Once you know the mean and the median, subtract the median from the mean and match that difference to the closest answer choice.
Desmos Guide
Use Desmos to verify the mean
In Desmos, type the expression for the mean:
Desmos will simplify this expression to a constant decimal; that decimal is the mean of the data set. Note its value.
Model a specific case to find the median
Set in Desmos (for example, type a = 1). Then define a list of data reflecting the table for , such as:
L = {1, 2, 2, 3, 3, 3, 4, 4, 5, 10}
Now type median(L); the value Desmos returns is the median for this distribution (and it will be the same for any positive integer ). Note this value.
Compare mean and median
In Desmos, type a final expression that subtracts the median from the mean, using the values you observed (for example, mean_value - median(L) if you stored the mean). The resulting decimal is how much greater the mean is than the median; compare this number with the answer choices to select the correct one.
Step-by-step Explanation
Use the frequency table to find the total number of values
Add the frequencies to confirm how many data points are in the set:
So there are data values in the set (as stated in the problem).
Compute the total sum of all the data values
Multiply each value by its frequency and add:
- Value appears times: contributes .
- Value appears times: contributes .
- Value appears times: contributes .
- Value appears times: contributes .
- Value appears times: contributes .
- Value appears times: contributes .
Now add these contributions:
So the sum of all data values is .
Find the mean of the data set
The mean is
The in the numerator and denominator cancels:
So the mean of the data set is .
Locate the median’s position in the ordered list
There are data values, which is an even number. For values, the median is the average of the -th and -st values in order.
List the cumulative counts as you go up through the values:
- All the 1s occupy positions through .
- All the 2s then occupy positions through (because ).
- All the 3s then occupy positions through (because ).
The -th and -st positions are between and . Since this whole block is made of the value , both the -th and -st values are .
Compute the median and subtract from the mean
From the previous step, both middle positions are , so the median is
The mean is , so the difference "mean minus median" is
Therefore, the mean of the data set is greater than the median, which corresponds to choice C.