Question 48·Hard·One-Variable Data Distributions; Measures of Center and Spread
A set of 9 distinct integers has a mean of and a median of . When the greatest integer in the set is removed, the mean of the remaining 8 integers decreases to and the range decreases by .
What is the greatest integer in the original set?
For SAT questions involving mean and removing or adding numbers, immediately convert each mean into a total sum by multiplying mean × number of values. Then compare the totals: the difference between the original total and the new total is exactly the value that was removed (or added). Only after you have that value do you briefly check extra information like median or range to ensure it’s consistent, but don’t let that extra data distract you from the quick, direct calculation using sums.
Hints
Turn means into totals
Use . What is the total sum of the 9 integers if their mean is ? What is the total sum of the remaining 8 integers if their mean is ?
Connect the two sums
Let be the greatest integer that gets removed. How are the sum of all 9 integers, the sum of the remaining 8 integers, and related by a simple subtraction?
Think about what was removed
Once you write an equation involving the two sums and , solve for . You do not actually need to use the median or range to compute ; they just provide consistency checks.
Desmos Guide
Compute the two sums from the means
In one expression line, type 9*12 to see the total of the 9 integers. In another line, type 8*10 to see the total of the remaining 8 integers.
Find the removed (greatest) integer
In a new line, type 9*12 - 8*10. The value Desmos displays for this expression is the integer that was removed, which is the greatest integer in the original set.
Step-by-step Explanation
Use the mean of 9 integers to find their total
"Mean" (average) is defined as
You are told that a set of 9 distinct integers has a mean of . So the sum of all 9 integers is
You are also told the median is , which means that if the integers are ordered from least to greatest, the 5th number is . (We don’t actually need the median to compute the greatest integer, but it is consistent information.)
Use the new mean after removing the greatest integer
When the greatest integer is removed, there are now 8 integers left, and their mean is .
Using the same mean formula,
Relate the two sums to the removed integer
Originally, the sum of all 9 integers was . After removing the greatest integer (call it ), the sum of the remaining 8 integers is .
So the removed integer must account for the difference between these two sums:
Now we just need to evaluate this difference to find . (Notice we still haven’t used the range information; we’ll see that it checks out after we find .)
Compute the greatest integer and check the range condition
Compute the difference:
So the greatest integer in the original set is .
As a quick check using the range information: let the original maximum be and the original minimum be . The original range is . After removing , the new maximum is the second-largest number. Because the range decreases by , the new maximum must be , and the new range is , which is indeed less than the original range.
Therefore, the greatest integer in the original set is , which corresponds to answer choice C.