Question 3·Hard·One-Variable Data Distributions; Measures of Center and Spread
The frequency table summarizes a data set of the daily high temperatures, in degrees Celsius, recorded at a greenhouse for 51 consecutive days.
| Temperature (°C) | Frequency |
|---|---|
| 18 | 4 |
| 19 | 5 |
| 20 | 6 |
| 21 | 9 |
| 22 | 10 |
| 23 | 8 |
| 24 | 5 |
| 25 | 4 |
On the next day, a thermometer malfunction produced a reading of . This value is added to the original data set, creating a new data set of 52 temperatures.
Which statement best compares the mean and median of the new data set to the mean and median of the original data set?
For questions about how adding a value changes the mean and median, avoid recomputing everything from scratch if possible. Remember that the mean depends on both the total sum and the number of data points: if the sum stays the same but the count increases, the mean must go down. For the median, focus on positions in the ordered list: determine which position(s) represent the median before and after the change, and track how inserting a new value—especially if it is the smallest or largest—shifts those positions. Then match your qualitative conclusions (mean up/down, median up/down/same) to the answer choice, rather than trying to calculate exact values under time pressure.
Hints
Think about the effect of adding 0 on the mean
Compare the new value (0°C) to the other temperatures. How does adding a value that is much smaller than the others affect the average?
Locate the original median using positions
There are 51 data points. For an odd number of data points, which position (1st, 2nd, 3rd, ...) is the median? Use the cumulative frequencies to find which temperature is at that position.
See how positions shift when you add 0
When you add a new value of 0°C, it will go at the very beginning when the data are ordered. How does this change the positions of the existing values? Which original positions now become the 26th and 27th values in the new list of 52 data points?
Compare old and new middle values
Once you know which temperatures are at the middle positions before and after adding 0, decide whether the median changes. Then compare the old and new means to see whether the mean increased, decreased, or stayed the same.
Desmos Guide
Compute the original mean with lists
In Desmos, define the temperature and frequency lists:
- Type
T = [18,19,20,21,22,23,24,25] - Type
F = [4,5,6,9,10,8,5,4]Then on a new line, typemean0 = sum(T*F) / sum(F)and look at the decimal value ofmean0for the original mean.
Compute the new mean after adding 0°C
On a new line, type mean1 = sum(T*F) / (sum(F) + 1). This uses the same total sum but increases the number of data points by 1. Compare the values of mean0 and mean1 in Desmos to see whether the mean increased or decreased.
(Optional) Verify medians with a full data list
If you want to check the median using Desmos, you can build the full list of 51 temperatures, for example: L0 = [18,18,18,18,19,19,19,19,19,20,20,20,20,20,20,...] continuing according to the frequencies, and then type median(L0) to see the original median. For the new data set, define L1 = [0, L0] or manually add 0 at the start, and then type median(L1) to see the new median; compare the two medians.
Step-by-step Explanation
Find the mean of the original data set
To find the original mean, first compute the total of all 51 temperatures.
Multiply each temperature by its frequency and add:
There are 51 days, so the original mean is
Keep this value in mind for comparison later.
Determine the mean of the new data set
In the new data set, you add one more value, 0°C.
- The new sum is (the total does not change).
- The new number of values is .
So the new mean is
You will compare this value to the original mean in the final step.
Find the median of the original and new data sets
First, find the original median.
With 51 data points (an odd number), the median is the value in position
when the data are listed in order.
Use cumulative frequencies to locate the 26th value:
- 18°C: positions 1–4
- 19°C: positions 5–9
- 20°C: positions 10–15
- 21°C: positions 16–24
- 22°C: positions 25–34
So the 26th value is 22°C. That is the original median.
Now, add one more value of 0°C. This becomes the very first value when the data are ordered.
- The new data set has 52 values (an even number).
- The median is the average of the 26th and 27th values.
Because the 0°C reading is inserted at the very beginning, every original value moves one position to the right:
- New position 2 = old position 1
- New position 3 = old position 2
- ...
- New position 26 = old position 25
- New position 27 = old position 26
From the original data, both the 25th and 26th values are 22°C (they are in the 22°C group, positions 25–34). So, in the new data set, the 26th and 27th values are both 22°C, and their average is also 22°C.
So the original median is 22°C, and the new median is also 22°C.
Compare both measures and match the statement
From the calculations:
- Original mean:
- New mean:
Since the total stayed the same but there are more data points, the new mean is less than the original mean.
For the median, we found that both the original and new medians are 22°C, so the medians are equal.
Therefore, the correct comparison is: The mean of the new data set is less than the mean of the original data set, and the medians of the two data sets are equal.