Question 27·Hard·One-Variable Data Distributions; Measures of Center and Spread
Data set M and data set N each consist of 36 values. The table shows how many times each value occurs in the two data sets.
| Value | Data set M frequency | Data set N frequency |
|---|---|---|
| 5 | 4 | 1 |
| 7 | 6 | 3 |
| 9 | 8 | 5 |
| 11 | 10 | 7 |
| 13 | 6 | 9 |
| 15 | 2 | 11 |
Which statement correctly compares the means and medians of the two data sets?
For frequency-table questions comparing means and medians, avoid listing all data points. First, use the total count to locate the median positions (for 36 numbers, use the 18th and 19th) and use cumulative frequencies to see which values occupy those positions in each set. Next, compute each mean as a weighted average: multiply each value by its frequency, add these products to get the total sum, then divide by the total number of data points. Finally, compare which data set has the larger mean and which has the larger median, and select the option whose wording matches both comparisons at once.
Hints
Use the fact that there are 36 values
Since each data set has 36 values, what positions in the ordered list do you need to look at to find the median? How can you use the frequencies in the table to figure out which values sit in those positions?
Locate the median using cumulative counts
For each data set, start adding the frequencies from the smallest value up until you pass the 18th and 19th positions. Which actual data values sit at those positions?
Use frequencies to compute the mean efficiently
Instead of writing out all 36 numbers, multiply each value by how many times it appears, add these products to get the total sum, then divide by 36. Do this for both data sets and then compare the results.
Compare your results to the wording of the options
Once you know which data set has the larger mean and which has the larger median, look for the choice whose wording matches both comparisons at the same time.
Desmos Guide
Use Desmos to compute the mean of data set M
In an expression line, type the weighted sum for data set M divided by 36:
(54 + 76 + 98 + 1110 + 136 + 152) / 36
The value that Desmos returns is the mean of data set M.
Compute the mean of data set N and compare
In another expression line, type the corresponding expression for data set N:
(51 + 73 + 95 + 117 + 139 + 1511) / 36
Compare this output to the one from Step 1 to see which data set has the larger mean, then combine that with your hand-calculated medians to choose the answer choice that matches both comparisons.
Step-by-step Explanation
Identify what you need to compare
You must compare both the mean and the median of data set M with those of data set N.
- Each data set has 36 values.
- Median: For 36 ordered numbers, the median is the average of the 18th and 19th values.
- Mean: Mean for each data set.
We will use the frequencies to find where the 18th and 19th values fall (for the median) and to compute the total sum (for the mean).
Find the median of data set M
Use cumulative frequencies to locate the 18th and 19th values for data set M.
For data set M:
- Value 5 occurs 4 times: positions 1–4
- Value 7 occurs 6 times: positions 5–10
- Value 9 occurs 8 times: positions 11–18
- Value 11 occurs 10 times: positions 19–28
- Value 13 occurs 6 times: positions 29–34
- Value 15 occurs 2 times: positions 35–36
The 18th value is the last 9, and the 19th value is the first 11.
So the median of M is
Find the median of data set N
Now do the same for data set N.
For data set N:
- Value 5 occurs 1 time: position 1
- Value 7 occurs 3 times: positions 2–4
- Value 9 occurs 5 times: positions 5–9
- Value 11 occurs 7 times: positions 10–16
- Value 13 occurs 9 times: positions 17–25
- Value 15 occurs 11 times: positions 26–36
The 18th and 19th values both fall in the block of 13s, so both are 13.
Thus the median of N is
So the median of M is 10 and the median of N is 13, meaning the median of M is less than the median of N.
Compute and compare the means
Use the frequencies to compute the total sum for each data set, then divide by 36.
Data set M:
So the mean of M is
Data set N:
So the mean of N is
Therefore, the mean of M is less than the mean of N.
Match your comparisons to the answer choices
From the work:
- Median: and , so .
- Mean: and , so .
So both the mean and the median of data set M are less than the corresponding values for data set N. The statement that says this is: “The mean and median of data set M are both less than the mean and median of data set N.”