A study with both random selection and random assignment calls for two separate checks: who the results can describe and whether the treatment caused a difference. Track who actually joined, since randomly choosing people to invite does not mean the participants are a random sample. Then match the reported group average, rather than promising a change for every person.
Hints
- Hint 1
A random sample uses chance to choose the people whose results will represent a larger group. Here, chance chose the people invited, but who decided whether an invited employee joined?
- Hint 2
With random assignment, chance chooses each participant’s group. That can support a cause-and-effect comparison among participants, even if those participants volunteered.
- Hint 3
A mean is a group average. One group can have a lower mean even if not every person in that group has a lower score. Does a choice describe averages or promise a result for everyone?
Step-by-step
Track participation, assignment, and the result
Step 1Set the limit on who the result describes
No Desmos needed. The conclusion depends on how people entered the study, not on arithmetic. The researchers randomly selected employees to invite, but only volunteered. Those who joined might differ from those who did not. Random invitation does not mean random participation. So the results cannot safely describe all invitees or all employees.
- Step 2
Use the random assignment
The volunteers were randomly assigned: chance chose which attended meditation and which continued their usual routines. The latter are the control group, the group used for comparison. Because the volunteers did not choose their own groups, a difference between the groups’ averages supports a causal effect of the assigned treatment for these participants.
- Step 3
Match the conclusion to the measured result
The researchers found a lower mean stress score for the meditation group. A mean is an average, so that result does not say meditation lowered every person’s stress. Among the volunteers who completed the study, those assigned to meditation had a lower average stress score than those in the control group. Choice B.