Question 48·Hard·Area and Volume
A right circular cone has a height of and a base radius of . A right circular cylinder is to be inscribed in the cone so that the base of the cylinder lies on the base of the cone and the top of the cylinder touches the lateral surface of the cone all the way around.
What is the greatest possible volume, in cubic centimeters, of such a cylinder?
For problems about a cylinder inscribed in a cone, always draw a cross-section and use similar triangles to connect the cylinder’s radius and height, reducing the volume formula to a function of a single variable. Then maximize that function efficiently—either by taking a derivative if you know basic calculus or, on the SAT with Desmos available, by graphing the function and finding its peak. Remember that positive constant factors (like or numerical coefficients) do not affect where the maximum occurs, so you can ignore them while locating the optimal dimension and only include them when computing the final volume.
Hints
Draw and label a cross-section
Sketch the cone with the inscribed cylinder and draw a cross-section through the axis. Label the cone’s height () and base radius (), and the cylinder’s height () and radius (). What smaller cone is formed above the cylinder?
Use similar triangles
In your cross-section, compare the large triangle for the whole cone with the smaller triangle from the tip of the cone down to the top of the cylinder. How can you set up a proportion between their heights and radii to relate and ?
Express volume in one variable
Once you have in terms of , substitute it into so that depends only on . Remember that multiplying by a positive constant does not change where the maximum occurs.
Find the maximum of the volume function
You will get a function like . Think about how to find the value of that makes this expression as large as possible—either by taking a derivative if you know calculus or by graphing this function and looking for its highest point.
Desmos Guide
Define the radius as a function of height
In Desmos, enter the expression r(h) = (10/24)*(24 - h) to represent the cylinder’s radius in terms of its height (from the similar-triangles relation).
Define the volume function
Enter V(h) = pi*(r(h))^2*h and, if you like, restrict the domain with {0 < h < 24} so you only see realistic cylinder heights inside the cone.
Graph and locate the maximum
Look at the graph of . Use Desmos’s maximum feature (type maximum(V, a, b) for an interval like maximum(V, 0, 24) or tap the highest point on the curve). The -coordinate gives the cylinder’s optimal height, and the corresponding value is the greatest possible volume.
Match with an answer choice
Compare the numerical value of the maximum shown in Desmos with the answer choices (all are multiples of ). Ignore in the calculator’s decimal and match the coefficient to select the correct option.
Step-by-step Explanation
Set up the picture and variables
Consider a vertical cross-section through the axis of the cone and the cylinder. This gives an isosceles triangle (the cone) and a rectangle (the cylinder).
- The cone has height cm and base radius cm.
- Let the cylinder have height and radius .
- The base of the cylinder is on the base of the cone, so the top of the cylinder is at height above the base of the cone.
Our goal is to express the cylinder’s volume in terms of a single variable (either or ) so we can maximize it.
Use similar triangles to relate radius and height
Look at the cone above the top of the cylinder.
- The whole cone has height and base radius .
- The smaller cone on top (from the cone’s tip down to the top of the cylinder) has height and radius .
These two cones are similar, so their corresponding sides are in proportion:
Solve for :
This gives the cylinder’s radius in terms of its height .
Write the volume as a function of height
The volume of the cylinder is
Substitute :
Simplify the constant:
so
To find the height that maximizes , we only need to maximize the factor
because is just a positive constant multiplier.
Find the height that maximizes the volume
We want the maximum of for .
Using derivatives (calculus approach):
Differentiate :
Set :
So
which gives or .
At or , the volume is , so those are minimum cases. The non-endpoint critical value cm gives the maximum volume.
Compute the maximum volume
Now use to find and then the volume.
From the similar-triangles relation
substitute :
Now compute the volume:
So the greatest possible volume of such a cylinder is , which corresponds to choice B.