Question 135·Hard·Systems of Two Linear Equations in Two Variables
Consider the system of equations
For which of the following values of does the system have no solution?
For systems of two linear equations with a parameter, quickly connect the algebra to the geometry: think of each equation as a line. Use the coefficient (or slope) conditions: for no solution, the lines must be parallel but distinct, which happens when the ratios of the - and -coefficients match but the ratio involving the constants does not. On test day, either write both equations in slope-intercept form and set the slopes equal, or apply the ratio rule directly: , then check which answer choice for the parameter satisfies this condition.
Hints
Connect “no solution” to the geometry of lines
Think about what it means graphically for two linear equations in and to have no solution. How are their lines positioned in the coordinate plane?
Inspect the slopes of the two lines
Rewrite each equation in the form (being careful with the parameter ) to identify the slopes of both lines in terms of .
Find when the lines are parallel
Set the slopes equal to each other and solve for ; these -values make the lines parallel. Then, check whether the corresponding lines are actually different (so they don't intersect) rather than being the same line.
Use the answer choices
After you find the algebraic condition on , see which of the given choices satisfy it and give parallel but distinct lines.
Desmos Guide
Enter the general equations with a slider for k
Type the two equations into Desmos exactly as given: (k+1)x - 3y = 4 and 2x - (k-1)y = 5. Desmos will create a slider for k so you can adjust its value.
Test each answer choice for k
For each choice (, , , and ), set the slider k to that value (for , type sqrt(7) in the slider input). Look at the graphs of the two lines in each case.
Identify when there is no intersection
For each tested value of k, check whether the two lines intersect. The value of k that makes the lines parallel and not intersect anywhere on the graph corresponds to the correct answer choice.
Step-by-step Explanation
Interpret “no solution” for a system of two linear equations
Each equation in the system represents a line in the -plane.
- If the lines intersect once, there is exactly one solution.
- If they are the same line, there are infinitely many solutions.
- If they are parallel but different, they will never intersect, so there is no solution.
So we want values of that make the two equations represent parallel, distinct lines.
Write each equation in slope-intercept form to see the slopes
Start with the first equation:
Solve for :
So the slope of the first line is
Now take the second equation:
Solve for (this works as long as so we are not dividing by 0):
So the slope of the second line is
Set slopes equal so the lines are parallel
For the lines to be parallel (and thus possibly have no solution), their slopes must be equal:
Cross-multiply:
Expand the left side:
Add 1 to both sides:
So any value of with makes the lines parallel. These are our candidate values for producing no solution.
Check that the lines are different (not the same line)
Parallel lines give no solution only if they are different lines. If they were the same line, there would be infinitely many solutions.
Using slope-intercept form from Step 2:
- First line: has -intercept .
- Second line: has -intercept .
For the two lines to be the same, we would need both the slopes and the intercepts to be equal. We already forced the slopes to match by using .
Now check whether the intercepts could also be equal:
Drop the negative signs:
Cross-multiply:
This value does not satisfy , so when the intercepts are different. That means for the lines are parallel and distinct, so the system has no solution.
The equation gives , and among the answer choices the matching value is , which is choice D.