Question 116·Medium·Systems of Two Linear Equations in Two Variables
One of the two equations in a system of linear equations is given:
The system has no solution. Which of the following could be the second equation in the system?
For SAT questions about how many solutions a system of two linear equations has, quickly compare either slopes or coefficient ratios. First, simplify one equation if possible (divide out common factors). Then: if the slopes are different, the system has one solution; if the equations are exact multiples (including the constant), there are infinitely many solutions; if the and coefficients are proportional but the constant is not, the lines are parallel and the system has no solution. Use coefficient ratios to avoid time-consuming graphing or algebra.
Hints
What does "no solution" look like on a graph?
Think about how two lines on a coordinate plane would have no point in common. How must they be positioned relative to each other?
Compare slopes using coefficients
Instead of graphing, use the coefficients of and to compare slopes. How can you tell if two lines are parallel just by looking at their equations?
Look for proportional coefficients
Try simplifying first (for example, divide by 3). Then check each choice: which ones keep the same ratio between the and coefficients as the simplified equation?
Don’t forget the constant term
For two equations to represent the same line, all three numbers (coefficients of , , and the constant) must be proportional. Which choice has matching and ratios but a different constant ratio?
Desmos Guide
Graph the original equation
In Desmos, type 9x - 12y = 36. This will graph the first line in the system.
Graph each answer choice one at a time
Add each option as a new line in Desmos: -3x + 4y = 10, -3x + 4y = -12, 3x + 4y = 36, and 21x - 28y = 84. You can hide/show them using the checkboxes to focus on one pair at a time with the original line.
Look for a pair of parallel, non-overlapping lines
For each candidate equation together with 9x - 12y = 36, observe whether the lines intersect. If they cross at a point, the system has a solution. If they lie exactly on top of each other, there are infinitely many solutions. You are looking for the option where the line has the same slope as the original but never intersects it on the graph.
Confirm using slopes if desired
If you want to double-check, click on each line and have Desmos show them in slope-intercept form . The correct choice will have the same slope as the original line but a different (vertical intercept), confirming they are parallel and distinct.
Step-by-step Explanation
Interpret "no solution" for a system of linear equations
For two linear equations in and , the solutions are the points where their graphs (lines) intersect.
- One solution: lines intersect at exactly one point (different slopes).
- Infinitely many solutions: lines are the same line (all coefficients are proportional, including the constant).
- No solution: lines are parallel but different (the and coefficients are proportional, but the constants are not proportional).
Simplify the given equation to see its pattern
The first equation is
Divide everything by to make the numbers smaller:
This has the same line as the original, just a simpler version. Now the pattern of coefficients is clear: with , with , and constant . Any parallel line must keep the same ratio for and .
Set up the condition for no solution
For a second equation to create no solution with :
- Its and coefficients must be in the same ratio (so the slopes match and the lines are parallel).
- Its constant term must not match that ratio (so it is a different, parallel line, not the same line).
So we are looking for an equation that is a constant multiple of on the left side, but not the same multiple on the right side.
Test each choice against the condition
First rewrite the given equation in the simpler form we found:
- Given: becomes .
Now compare each option to :
- A) can be rewritten by multiplying both sides by :
The and coefficients match and (same ratio), but the constant is not . So this is a parallel but different line → no solution.
- B) becomes after multiplying by , which is exactly the same equation as the original → infinitely many solutions, not none.
- C) has coefficients and , not and , so the slopes are different → one solution.
- D) divides by to give , again exactly the same line → infinitely many solutions.
Only choice A) gives coefficients in the same ratio for and but a different constant, so it is the correct second equation for a system with no solution.