Question 151·200 Super-Hard SAT Math Questions·Advanced Math
. Given that , , , and are integers, which choice must be true?
For “equivalent expressions” questions with a factored form, expand the product and match coefficients. When the question asks what must be true, translate the constraints (like and ) into a small set of cases (factor pairs), then use parity/modular reasoning (often mod 2 or mod 4) to find an invariant that holds in every case.
Hints
Expand and compare
Expand and match the , , and constant terms with .
Use the constant term first
From the constant term you’ll get an equation involving and . Use it to decide whether and must be even or odd.
Consider the possibilities for
List the integer factor pairs of 8 (including sign). Think about whether and are odd/even in each case.
Work modulo 4
Using and the parity information, decide whether can ever be divisible by 4.
Desmos Guide
Create lists of possible integer factor pairs
In Desmos, enter lists for possible values:
A=[-8,-4,-2,-1,1,2,4,8]
Then compute the matching list:
C=8/A
(These are all integers because each value in A divides 8.)
List possible values and compute
Enter the divisors of 15:
L=[-15,-5,-3,-1,1,3,5,15]
Then compute:
M=-15/L
Test examples with sliders (quick check)
Create sliders for indices i and j (integers) so you can pick one value from each list:
- set
ifrom 1 tolength(A) - set
jfrom 1 tolength(L)
Define:
a=A[i], c=C[i], l=L[j], m=M[j]
Then compute:
b=a*l-m*c
Check divisibility by 4 across cases
Move the sliders through different valid combinations and compute the remainder when dividing by 4 using Desmos syntax, for example:
r=mod(b,4)
You’ll observe r is never 0, which supports that is not a multiple of 4.
Step-by-step Explanation
Expand and match coefficients
Expand:
Match with to get
Use the constant term to get parity for and
Since is odd, both and must be odd integers.
List the possible parities of and from
Because , the integer pairs must make one of these parity situations happen:
- One of is odd and the other is even (e.g., or , with possible negative signs).
- Both and are even (e.g., or , with possible negative signs).
Determine in each situation
Recall with odd.
Case 1: one of is odd and the other is even. Then is oddodd odd, while is oddeven even, so odd even odd. Therefore, cannot be divisible by 4.
Case 2: both and are even. The only (absolute) factor pairs are or .
- If , then . Here is odd and is even, so is odd, making .
- If , then . Here is even and is odd, so is odd, again making .
Conclude the statement that must be true
In Case 1, is odd, so it is not divisible by 4. In Case 2, , so it is also not divisible by 4.
Therefore, the statement that must be true is is not a multiple of 4.