Question 10·200 Super-Hard SAT Math Questions·Problem Solving and Data Analysis
Data set consists of 25 different values that have a minimum of 20, a maximum of 80, a mean of 50, and a standard deviation of 12. The values 20 and 80 are removed from the data set to create data set . Which choice is true?
When values are removed from a data set, check if they're symmetric around the mean (equal distances above and below). If so, the mean stays the same. For standard deviation, remember that extreme values (far from the mean) contribute most to the spread. Removing extreme values decreases standard deviation; removing values close to the mean has less effect.
Hints
Think about what happens to the mean
You're removing 20 and 80 from a data set with mean 50. What is the average of 20 and 80? How does removing values that average to the mean affect the overall mean?
Think about what standard deviation measures
Standard deviation measures how spread out values are from the mean. The values 20 and 80 are the minimum and maximum—the farthest from the mean. What happens to the spread when you remove the most extreme values?
Put it together
Removing values that are symmetric around the mean keeps the mean the same. Removing the values farthest from the mean reduces the spread.
Desmos Guide
Create a sample data set A
Enter a list of 25 values with min 20, max 80, and mean 50:
Verify:
Create data set B by removing 20 and 80
Remove the first and last values:
Compare mean and standard deviation
Calculate:
Confirm that the means are equal and that .
Step-by-step Explanation
Determine what happens to the mean
The mean of data set is 50.
We're removing 20 and 80. Notice that:
- 20 is 30 below the mean
- 80 is 30 above the mean
These two values are symmetric around the mean, so their average is exactly 50.
When you remove values whose average equals the mean, the mean stays the same.
Therefore, the mean of is also 50.
Determine what happens to the standard deviation
Standard deviation measures how spread out the data is from the mean.
- Values close to the mean contribute little to the spread
- Values far from the mean contribute a lot to the spread
The values being removed (20 and 80) are the minimum and maximum—they're the farthest possible values from the mean of 50.
Removing the most extreme values always reduces the spread of the data.
Conclude the comparison
- Mean: Stays the same (removed values average to 50)
- Standard deviation: Decreases (removed the most extreme values)
The answer is: The mean of data set is the same as the mean of data set , and the standard deviation of data set is less than the standard deviation of data set .